![]() I personally heard this from him in Cape Town. Btw he considers the ENTIRE narration to be FORGED not just weak. I wondering when this was going to be next on the list after the door to this fitna was opened by Shaykh Ninowy. So who are all these “sectarian judges” who are desperate to save jannat for themselves and throw everyone else in the fire? can you name some names please? So you’re saying that Ahlus Sunnah is equal in guidance to the rafidis (such as yourself), ismailis, khawarij, wahabis, etc. No doubt the sectarian judges are desperate to save jannat for themselves and throw everyone else into fire!ĪbdalQadir time to move along! will check pm’s. And there is no judgment on them in the authentic hadith, In Quran kareem, the Ummah is called as the Best Ummah and all 73 sects are the ummah as the sahih hadith says. This in turn makes a sufficient case for the rejection of the addition whilst accepting that the sahih report is the one that mentions My Ummah will be divided into 73 sects. Many prominent hadith scholars considered the ‘addition’ at most a fabrication and at least a weak hadith. ![]() That this addition of 72 in hell-fire except one has been weakened by a large number of hadith scholars and so much so that Ibn Hazm has declared it as a fabrication! Imam al-shawkani in his fath al-qadeer says: Imam Ibn Wazir al-Yamani in his al-awasim wal-qawasim says: Beware! Do not be deceived by this addition ‘all in hell fire except one’ because it is a baseless fabrication. However, let me just give you two references from the great hadith masters who have dismissed this addition in various reports which say 72 for hell-fire and one for paradise.ġ. So now, in Jami` al-Tirmadhi, we have only two reports in this matter and only the first one is authentic and the second one which has Hell-fire for 72 is weak and problematic.Īlso consider that the Qur`an Paak says that You are the best Ummat and the sahih version of this hadith in trimazi says that my ummah will be divided into 73 sects so 73 sects also belong to the best ummat! There is more but this makes the point sufficiently. For example Imam ibn Hanbal says that he is munkar al-hadith meaning a rejected reporter, and Imam Yahya ibn maeen, the great rijal imam, says that he is a weak reporter. In rijal literature, he is a rejected reporter. Whats more is that the reason it is a strange one is because it has a reporter abd al-rahman al-ifriqi in it who is considered to be a weak one according to many. Now, the first one, from abu hurayra is authentic but mentions NO HELLFIRE for all 72 sects except one and the one that mentions hellfire for 72 is considered Gharib even according to imam al-tirmadhi. We do not know any other route of reporters except this unique one! Imam Trimazi then comments: this hadith is Gharib (strange in terms of narrators) meaning there is only one route of it, etc. There is no mention of one will go to jannah and others will go to hell in this authentic version of the hadith.Ģ. It has two reports on the matter, one from Abu Hurayra (r) and the other from abdullah ibn amr(r).ġ.Īt the end Imam Tirmazi comments that this hadith is sahih hasan. As an example, Let us study how it is reported in al-Tirmadhi-one of the six sahih books. The 73 sects hadith appears in numerous hadith books and save a couple of reports, all have a problem of authenticity. ![]() I thought, I may as well share it with you all though the complete version will be published on my blog when it is ready. ![]() It was a reply to a dear brother via pm on fb. Below is a work in progress about 73-Sects Hadith and by no means the final analysis and the conclusions are provisional. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Details
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |